There are very few tanks I would put gravel in and those have huge fish like oscars who would kick up sand too much. Shrimp sand vs gravel. Today I would like to talk about bare bottom tanks, sand, and gravel as a substrate. Jul 1, 2014. frogfan. One of the first purchases most aquarists will make for a new aquarium, be it freshwater, saltwater, reef, discus, goldfish, cichlid or any other – is the gravel and substrate.It could be sand, crushed coral, Fluorite, neon pink pebbles, glass marbles or countless other materials but it all tends to be the very first thing to go into an empty aquariums. The gravel vs. sand debate often depends on what type of fish you are keeping and what type of tank you have. Hi, I'm returning to the hobby after a long absence and starting up my old Oceanic 58g. However this means you will see every bit of waste the fish leave behind, almost as much as with a bare bottom tank. Shrimp sand vs gravel Sign in to follow this . A range of Aquarium Substate , Sand & Gravel to suit both freshwater & Marine Fish Tanks. The biggest difference between sand and gravel is that if you buy a high quality sand, with a relatively uniform grain size, you will have a much easier time maintaining your water quality. Fish: 2 mollies 1 platty 1 neon 2 guppies . of gravel for each gallon. Gravel collects foodstuffs and debris, and allows it to rot inside and sink further into the substrate, so unless you siphon/vacuum very well, there will always be some kind of build-up. It is however, easier to use a siphon tube to clean the substrate as the gravel won’t get sucked up. This article is the first in our new series where we will look at the elements of hardscaping in a planted tank in greater detail. Substrate for the aquarium tank is often overlooked but choosing the perfect one will make you Aquarium look amazing. Personally, I like the look of sand but when you hear some of the problems people have with, although most are from people with no experience with it, it just seems a pain to deal with. and 3 glofish. Aquarium Sand vs Gravel? But some fish like corys prefer sand over gravel because of their whiskers.. While aquarium sand doesn’t allow the water to flow through it as well as gravel does, this does not matter too much if you have bottom feeders or burrowing fish, as they will sift through the sand to find food which will promote cleanliness. I'm waiting to move to upgrade the fish into a 50 gallon tank, but since money is tight i can't buy everything I need for the tank at once.. Now that we’ve briefly discussed the role and variations of sand in the wild, and how this connects to your reef tank, it’s time to get into the gritty topic of aquarium sand types. And you have to stir it once in a while. Sand VS. Gravel in my freshwater aquarium? bailey88 2 ... (Paratya Australiensis) for a small scale supply to private aquarium owners and … So, the sand will be gradually reduced after a while. Live sand is the same type of sand as dry sand except it comes packaged wet. Use one large rock or several stones arranged in groups. Sand looks natural and beautiful. As mentioned, certain fish and plants do better with sand instead of gravel. Freshwater Aquarium Sand vs Gravel: Comparison. A great option for stabilizing and enhancing pH is crushed coral. We’re reviewing gravel in this article, but there are some great options for aquarium sand as well. Equipment: automatic heater filter airstone bubbler 1 regular ligh bulb 1 plant light bulb aquarium gravel . 5,589 5.6K. I posted the question the other day what was best for catfish and my filter gravel, sand, or glass marbles and obviously arrived at the conclusion that sand was really the only option with catfish. I used to have sand but each time I siphoned the debris, the sand would be sucked out together from the tank. by Craig on Aug 9, 2020 As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. By bailey88, August 15, 2012 in Shrimp Tank Setup. But I find that water changes are difficult with sand. Recommended Posts. It is softer and gentler on fish and allows you to keep a wide variety of bottom dwelling species. Sent from my Z220 using Fish Lore Aquarium Fish Forum mobile app It made an aquarium maintenance job too easy and too fast, they saw what I … Popular Substrate to choose . But gravel isn’t your only option for an aquarium, and in many cases, sand can actually make a better choice Not only is sand cheaper, but it’s actually superior to gravel in several ways. Aquarium stones add accent and interest. Gravel vs. When shopping for aquarium gravel, it is critical to think over how deep does the tank gravel need to be. Followers 0. Sand would probably be better for roots to grow in. If you plan to buy tank gravel, keep in mind that you have to utilize 1 ½ lb. This keeps debris on top, and if there is sufficient water movement in the tank, the waste will be caught and removed by the aquarium filter . However, sand is more prone to clouding your water, it could damage filters, and there is a chance of toxic air chambers forming in the sand. Sand and aquarium soils are harder to maintain because gravel vacuums and filters can pick up the sediment along with the waste products. Aquarium sand vs. pool filter sand vs. play sand vs. other sand? Any waste will sit on top of the sand, allowing it to get stirred back up and hopefully sucked into the filter. Member. Using sand in your aquarium can help make your cleaning duties easier, as it doesn’t let waste filter down between the particles as easily as gravel or crushed coral, for example. If you cover the filter intakes and gravel vacs to prevent this they will leave more waste behind, which could hurt your fish and plants. I've heard good things about both, but my Goldies are substrate pickers. I want to use Flourite Black for substrate and I'm wondering if the gravel is better for roots since the sand is very fine and might compact too much. Is sand or gravel better for a planted aquarium? Some fish species prefer a sand substrate. So come down and visit us at Kellyville Pets today and make the right choice for you fishy friend! Freshwater aquarium sand can be pH neutral, while specialty blends are made for fish like African Cichlids that prefer hard water with a higher mineral content. Both gravel and sand share an equal spotlight to beautify your display. I have a 21 in. The Shifting Sands of Tank Perfection - Dry Sand vs Live Sand. Crushed Coral. Overall I will go with sand. Almost every aquascaper swears by soil, and there’s a good reason for this: unlike sand or gravel, soil is packed full with nutrients. Aquarium Sand vs Gravel: the Pros and Cons. (10 gallon) aquarium with a female guppy, 2 female platys, a betta, 3 goldfish, a pleco. Sand vs. Gravel HELP!!! !. Here, we are going to look at the most popular Gravel and Sand! We are going to look at the advantages and disadvantages of sand and gravel for our shrimp and fish. We will try to find the answer whether the substrate is even required. Treated Aquarium Sand. Firstly, gravel comes in different shapes, sizes, and colors that basically offer you a chance to customize your aquarium and give it a unique look. Agree with James: food doesn't get stuck in sand. Sand is better for catfish with sensitive barbels that can wear down over time on gravel. 10 Gallon Tank. It is this high nutrient content which promotes the desired strong plant growth, even with very demanding aquarium plants, such as lawn builders. Gravel, if the pebbles are really small, can also be good. Sand vs Gravel Which is easier to clean and maintain? So in this article, you will learn some great tips on how to clean aquarium sand. Different substrates like Argonite, Gravel, Sand, Crush coral, Vermiculate, Aquasoil, and Laterite are available. I actually had to stop using sand in clients' tanks because it was too easy to maintain. A detailed and helpful comparison of aquarium sand and gravel, we discuss the main pros and cons of each, if you have questions then here are the answers. Usually, gravel is better for most of the freshwater aquariums than sand. If you stuck the tube down into the sand like you would gravel, you would suck up sand. Contained within this moisture are billions of broad-spectrum marine bacteria but also carefully selected strains of marine bacteria to help begin the formation of your aquarium’s biological filter. But it looks really nice though... Gravel is much easier to vacuum, and I guess it looks nice too. Sand. Gravel is the right choice because they said the gaps between granules would allow water to flow, thereby reducing microbial growth. Gravel vs Sand? Sand vs. Gravel HELP!!! I bought a 20lbs bag of aquarium sand from Petco. Gravel requires a deeper cleaning typically with a gravel Get all the extra benefits by becoming a channel member. I'm going to be setting up my new goldfish aquarium tomorrow, and I'm torn between sand and gravel. By mrs.peace21, 7 years ago on Aquarium Plants. Aquarium Gravel vs Sand If your unsure about whether to use gravel or sand, our experienced staff in the aquarium section can help make the right choice. So sand vs gravel? Sand won’t allow food and waste to fall through the cracks like gravel will. They're in a gravel aquarium now and love to dig through the substrate, picking up pieces and spitting them back out. Many people choose to use sand instead of gravel for their the aquarium. Sand, on the other hand and depending on how fine of a sand you get, will not allow any debris or foodstuffs to pass. Free Delivery for all orders over $30.00 with AfterPay , ZipPay & ZipMoney Available at Checkout ! Aquarists will settle for the one that will serve a specific purpose. Sand is packed more closely than gravel and therefore doesn’t need cleaning as much, and food particles are less likely to get trapped underneath like they do in gravel tanks.